Видео

This comparison is not quantifiable. There are great stars in Rock: Tarja Turunen, Floor Jensen, Noora Louhima. There are no great ones in pop. Not there: Tina Turnen, Celine Dion, Whitney Houston, Diana Ross, Madonna. However, there are also a few rock greats: Manuela Kraler, Janis Jop[lin, Liv Kristine, Vibecke Stene. For me the clash is not decided.

watching nikki minaj and her stupid hairdo LIPSinc is atrocious.

it was not alway like this back in the 80s there was some very good singers in pop tina turner ,prince and many more but pop music these days is about as fake as it gets.

"I'll never meet the ground", but her name is Floor. Lol🤟😝😝😝 It didn't put Gaga to shame, tbh. No one could.☠️☠️☠️🤟

I'm Dutch, i should like Floor better, as a true patriot, but no, it's lady Gaga who i like better, but Floor does a good job!❤

Really who gives a shit. If you like metal and/or pop, great. But nobody has been "humiliated" here.

This comparison doesn’t make any sense at all. They’re all very good at their own styles.

A ghdzie największe gwiazdy popu? Gdzie Mylene Farner, Tina Turner, Celine Dion, Diana Ross, ... i inne. O fabetach nawet nie wsponę? Wystawiłeś największe armaty rocka, ale najewieksze armaty popu pominołeś.

Floor Floor Floor ❤

One of my favourite singers is Tatiana Shmayluk, not only for her screemo but beautiful 'regular' singing voice. Oh, and Brittney Slayes...oh no, you've opened pandoras box... RUclips rabbit hole here I come....

Except I’m familiar with all the pop artists in this video but I’ve never heard of any of these metal singers.

Im a metal fan, but no one can humiliate lady gaga or adele in vocals lol

Bom demais ❤ comentário BR que cê tá procurando 🎉

Gaga, very nasal. Jansen, clear and open vocals. That fact alone should say it all.

Floor is much better than Lady gaga

Rly? Lady Gaga?! Why not someone like Whitney Houston? or Beyonce? It's like putting Taylor Swift vs Pavarotti.

Tarja❤❤❤❤the one and only❤❤❤❤

Listening from Kenya. Epica never disappoints.

Gaga humiliated again 😂 Floor slays so hard it's not even a match. But honestly, Gaga was way better here than in the previous one.

It's not even a match. Gaga is competely out of tune and her voice sounds forced, bad technique, nose-sound. Floor's voice is like an angel's, beautiful head-tone, she fills the room with magic so effortlessly. I used to hate this song, but Floor sings it so well that I actually quite like her version. Kudos to Gaga for playing the piano though. She is not a bad singer, but this was just not her best performance.

Lady gaga 🤮🤮🤮🤢

Tf is this?

All mainstream music is Satanic. Old news.

Go again with zero auro tune

so u show us that this METAL singer r just boring ppl, good to know

Ouço esta banda desde 2009 e desde então não me canso! E hoje em 2024 ouvindo esta obra prima.

The pop stars are all lip synching

The only female pop singer who is good enough is Adele

Before I listened first time to Floor there had been several female singers I really liked. I still like them but... I now automatically compare them to Floor and most of them now do poorly. The richness, emotion and depth in Floor's voice is so catching it is hard to find another female singer who is able to sing this way. A lot of them are technically good, have beautiful voices but are missing this "Floor Extra". They are a beautiful covering without this rich contents you feel when Floor is singing.

Gaga is unbearable. I stopped.

This is DIVINE

I love them all

We can win this comparison with just Dutch symphonic metal singers + Marco Hietala. No contest.

Lady Gaga did a fine job writing and singing Shallow. Then Floor took it from her. Just like Johnny Cash took Hurt from some band.

Pop is good but metallic hit different levels

Floor wins of course, but I think Gaga’s vocals would be better in metal than pop because all that ❄️ has ruined her vocal cords. So her raspy voice definitely suits a deeper sound better.

Team Metalheads . 👇

Man you gotta be tone deaf or some sheit.

The only pop voice that is any good was Adele

To be fair...Gaga played 2 instruments... Floor only one...

the difference between clean Norwegian air and dust ridden USA celebraties...

Floor sings like Muhammad Ali boxed. With elegance and flair. While Lady Gaga sings like Mike Tyson used to fight. Sheer brute force.

Super epic

Llevo muchos años escuchando Épica y no me canso. Obra maestra tras obra maestra. Loco por ver a Simone en directo en España. Hay mucho metal sinfónico pero este grupo se sale de cualquier estereotipo. Sublime...

Lmao comparing Elize Ryd to Miley f**ing Cyrus...that's like comparing a 14kt diamond to a piece of limestone. 🤣

There should be no such thing as a “metal singer”.

Thumbs up for Within Temptation! Cool video over all :)

Yeah I love metal, but even still this is more great performances by talented singers. It's not like the pop singers weren't CLEARLY doing a good job live, while the metal singers were stomping all over them. Obviously I'd say the singing from the metal singers is clearly more impressive, and I think the range and accuracy of a great metal singer far surpasses most singers in nearly any genre, but that doesn't mean the pop singers were doing terribly. They were doing really well actually. It's differences in genre, and the kinds of things a metal singer does wouldn't make sense in pop songs. I think pop should definitely take more risks musically and try to expand itself, but if they did that it wouldn't be the major pop music stuff anymore.

this is something i have seen both men and women since the 80´s the usual comment from pop music people, metal singers just scream and some other negative points about the music in general. Theres only a few pop musicians that could ever compete with metal musicians, there are a few. I havent even touched the idea to use autotune in live music, its pathetic.

Good pop singers. I appreciate. But metal singers are way better. Period.